Family-run since 2011RBQ licence 5647-0479-01South Shore and Greater Montreal

(438) 255-2501Français

Walk-In Shower vs. Bathtub: What’s Right for Your South Shore Home?

Updated November 18, 2026 by Fabio Freire, Freire Management (RBQ 5647-0479-01)

This is one of the most common decisions in a South Shore bathroom renovation: do you keep the bathtub or convert it to a walk-in shower? The answer is not the same for every home or every homeowner. Here is how to think through it.

The Case for Converting to a Walk-In Shower

For most South Shore homeowners, the tub-to-shower conversion is the renovation they should have done years ago. Here is why:

  • You do not use the tub. If you shower every day and use the tub once a year, it is taking up valuable floor space in your bathroom. A large walk-in shower uses that same space better and makes your daily routine genuinely better.
  • A walk-in shower makes a small bathroom feel bigger. A frameless glass enclosure opens up the visual space. A large-format tiled shower feels intentional and luxurious even in a compact bathroom.
  • Walk-in showers are easier to maintain. No grout lines on a curved tub surround. No shower curtain. Frameless glass and large tile format is far easier to keep clean.
  • It is one of the highest-impact renovations per dollar. A well-executed tub-to-shower conversion transforms how the bathroom feels immediately.
Walk-in shower renovation South Shore Montreal
Custom walk-in shower by Freire Management

The Case for Keeping the Bathtub

There are situations where keeping a tub makes clear sense:

  • You have young children. If your kids are young and bath time is a daily reality, you need a tub. Converting your only tub to a shower and then redoing it in five years when the kids are older is expensive. Wait, or keep one tub if you have two bathrooms.
  • Resale in the near term. The general real estate guidance in Canada is that homes with no bathtub can be harder to sell to buyers with young children or buyers who simply want the option. If you are renovating to sell within two years, think carefully about whether to remove the only tub in the home.
  • You actually use it. If you take long baths regularly and it genuinely improves your life, keep it. A renovated soaker tub in a well-designed bathroom is not a bad choice.

The Best of Both: Two-Bathroom Homes

If your home has two full bathrooms, the decision is much simpler. Convert the primary ensuite to a walk-in shower with no tub. Keep a tub in the main bathroom for kids, guests and resale flexibility. This is the setup most South Shore families end up happy with long term.

Ready to Get a Real Number for Your Renovation?

We come to your home, walk the scope with you, and give you a detailed written estimate within a few days. No vague ranges, no pressure. Just an honest price from a team that delivers.

Book Your Free Consultation or call (438) 255-2501.

Bathroom renovation with freestanding tub Montreal
Bathroom transformation, South Shore

What Does a Tub-to-Shower Conversion Cost in Montreal?

A well-executed walk-in shower conversion on the South Shore typically runs $12,000 to $22,000. This includes:

  • Demolition of the existing tub and surround
  • Proper waterproofing membrane (not just tile)
  • Shower drain relocation if needed
  • Custom tile floor and walls
  • Frameless glass enclosure
  • Quality shower system with rainfall head
  • Niche or recessed shelf

This is a mid-range scope with quality materials. You can spend less with simpler tile and a basic shower head. You can spend more with heated floors, a steam system and custom stone tile.

What Makes a Walk-In Shower Worth the Investment?

The difference between a shower renovation that looks impressive for two years and one that looks impressive for twenty years comes down to a few key decisions:

Proper Waterproofing

The most important element no one talks about. Tile is not waterproof. Cement board is not waterproof. A proper waterproofing membrane under the tile is what keeps water from getting into the framing and causing mould and structural damage. Do not skip it or let a contractor tell you it is not necessary.

Large Format Tile

Large format tile (12×24 or larger) has fewer grout lines, is easier to clean and looks more contemporary. It also requires a flatter, better-prepared substrate to install correctly. If a contractor is not confident installing large format tile, it shows.

Frameless Glass

Frameless glass enclosures look cleaner and last longer than framed alternatives. The track at the bottom of framed shower doors collects soap scum and is difficult to clean. Frameless panels are easier to maintain and significantly better looking.

Which Neighbourhoods on the South Shore Are Doing This Most?

Tub-to-shower conversions are the most common bathroom renovation we complete across all of our South Shore markets. It is especially common in Candiac and Greenfield Park where 1990s and postwar builder bathrooms still have the original tub-shower combo. In Saint-Lambert and Saint-Bruno, the trend is toward full primary bathroom expansions that include a walk-in shower and a freestanding soaker tub, getting both in a larger footprint.

See what is typical in your area: Candiac, Saint-Lambert, Saint-Bruno, Greenfield Park.

Ready When You Are.

Tell us about your bathroom in 60 seconds and pick a time for your free onsite visit.

Book My Free VisitGet My Price in 60 Seconds

Free onsite visit · Detailed written quote · No obligation